ELEPHANTS IN OAKLAND
an Oakland Athletics Blog:
Pitching, Defense and the Three Run Jimmy-Jack


ELEPHANTS IN OAKLAND
Google
Web elephantsinoakland.com

Tuesday, July 27, 2004
BACK TO THE MAIN PAGE

 

KARROSTRACIZED



The season long nightmare for A's fans is over.

ERIC KARROS HAS BEEN DESIGNATED FOR ASSIGNMENT

.

UPDATE


According to Susan Slusser of the San Francisco Chronicle, Karros requested his release. Sort of. That is, if you believe this quote:
    "Sure, I wanted to get released. I'm sorry it didn't work out, but this is the best thing. It allows the A's a little more flexibility, and I'm not just taking up a roster spot.''
    - ERIC KARROS (from his SoCal Home)


Chris Hammond is coming off the DL and the decision was made to jettison the Karros Question and move on.

The Karros signing was a lightning rod of controversy for A's fans in the off-season and created a chasm between concept and reality. Stat heads and even casual fans wondered aloud why signing Karros was considered a 'good thing'. When the subject of Karros' ability to hit left-handers and as a right hand hitting pinch-hitter was mentioned, it was laughed off as drunken buffoonery. While Robert Buan, the A's Broadcasting Manager & Post-Game Show Host, shunned callers who suggested getting rid of Karros or that the signing was a mistake fans - even more fans lined up to be the first to moan about the aged 1st baseman. When fans would suggest bringing up cult-hero Graham Koonce or even Mike Edwards, Baun would shout, "And who do you send down? Koonce hits left-handed, so do Hatteberg and Durazo." Then, Baun would dismiss these callers as being unknowledgeable and Baun would continue to bow at alter of 'veteran' and toe the Scott-Hoffman Company Line.

The off-season signing off Karros was seen as a favor to owner Steve Schott who is a noted "friend" of Eric Karros. The ideal situation would have been for Karros to hit a little bit and be packaged in a trade in May or July. Or even supply some depth to the bench during the playoff push. However, Karros has been unable to hit anything but a proverbial wall and his defense resembles the same picture; a man hitting a wall. Karros' range is roughly whatever he can reach for without extending his elbow. His back problems do not allow him to even bend down far enough to pick up a ball in the dirt that is not moving. This was evident in Spring Training and continued into the season.

It's not like Karros is a bad guy, he's actually a very good guy and funny, too. He had the whole 5 O'clock shadow and late 1970's white Afro thing going and his early bitching and moaning about playing time was quickly put to rest. Let's face it, there's a reason that Steve Schott isn't a General Manager and that Billy Beane is. Owners shouldn't make baseball decisions. Well, owners of all 29 other teams should...just not the A's. Let Steinbrenner make as may decisions as he needs to. Same with the Mariners and Rangers.

So, Karros will hang on the 10-Day wire and the A's will be able to field offers and hopefully put something together to get a 'not-a-chance-in-hell' prospect to use as fodder. The funny thing is, there was a Litmus Test in place for Karros even before signing him.
    If the A's demote Player A (Karros):

  • Will the Player be a starter in AAA?

  • No.

  • Will the Player be a starter in AA?

  • No.

  • Will the Player be a starter in Modesto (High A Ball) or Kane County (Low A Ball)?

  • No.

So, why was he signed, again?

The aged veteran concept doesn't carry any weight, either, as Karros has never been to the World Series and didn't do a whole hell of a lot in the Dodgers Organization to perpetuate a Championship run. He wasn't even a good 1st baseman in the field or at the plate. He was a career pinch hitter who found a home. The most similar batters to Eric Karros according to Baseball Reference are Tino Martinez and Lee May. Yah.

Karros deserves an extended handshake and a wave. That's about it. And maybe someone could pick up his duffel bag and hand it to him since he may not be able to bend down and get it, like so many groundballs that went by him at first base. This is not a John Jaha heroic gesture by any means. Karros should have had the nerve to ask for his release or to be waived earlier in the season when Hatteberg and Durazo were both on fire. Now that we are coming to the dog days of summer and the September call-ups are around the corner, Karros was going to be squeezed, anyway. It was abundantly clear that Karros was a roster black hole and not a panacea for anything but a veteran seat warmer coming out of Spring Training.

DON'T LET THE DOOR HIT YOU IN THE ASS
Season TM G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO SB CS AVG OBP SLG OPS
1991 LA 1414 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 6 0 0 .071 .133 .143 .276
1992 LA 149 545 63 140 30 1 20 88 37 103 2 4 .257 .304 .426 .730
1993 LA 158 619 74 153 27 2 23 80 34 82 0 1 .247 .287 .409 .696
1994 LA 111 406 51 108 21 1 14 46 29 53 2 0 .266 .310 .426 .636
1995 LA 143 551 83 164 29 3 32 105 61 115 4 4 .298 .369 .535 .904
1996 LA 154 608 84 158 29 1 34 111 53 121 8 0 .260 .316 .479 .795
1997 LA 162 628 86 167 28 0 31 104 61 116 15 7 .266 .329 .459 .788
1998 LA 139 507 59 150 20 1 23 87 47 93 7 2 .296 .355 .475 .830
1999 LA 153 578 74 176 40 0 34 112 53 119 8 5 .304 .362 .550 .912
2000 LA 155 584 84 146 29 0 31 106 63 122 4 3 .250 .321 .459 .780
2001 LA 121 438 42 103 22 0 15 63 41 101 3 1 .235 .303 .388 .691
2002 LA 142 524 52 142 26 1 13 73 37 74 4 2 .271 .323 .399 .722
2003 ChC 114 336 37 96 16 1 12 40 28 46 1 1 .286 .340 .446 .786
2004 Oak 40 103 8 20 6 0 2 11 7 16 1 0 .194 .243 .311 .554
Total -- 1755 6441 797 1724 324 11 284 1027 552 1167 59 30 .268 .325 .450 .779
SEASONAL AVERAGES (per 162 games played)
Years G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO SB CS AVG OBP SLG OPS
10.83 162 595 74 159 30 1 26 95 51 108 5 3 .268 .325 .454 .779


Comments:

Post a Comment

Create a Link

Back to the Main Page


This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?


Looking for the old blog template?

KEVIN GOLDSTEIN
2005 Wrap-up
2004 BA's Top 10 Giants v A's
2004 BA's Top 10 Prospects


MATT WATSON
WATSON - Part 1
WATSON - Part 2

WATSON - Part 3


WILL CARROLL
THE JUICE

web Elephants In Oakland